G.I. Gurdjieff tried to break free of the ordinary life that binds everybody to
the mundane by deliberately adopting unconventional means and ways to lead his
life
An
enigmatic figure, Georgei Ivanovitch Gurdjieff was considered by some
to be the greatest mystical teacher of all time, and by others to be a
fraud. His philosophy, commonly called 'the Work', blazed a new trail
for occultism in the early 20th century, and paved the way for now-conventional
techniques of group and encounter therapy.
His central postulate was that people are no more than machines run by
forces outside their control. Human beings in such a state are essentially
asleep. In order to wake up, they must work hard to penetrate their normal
state of unconsciousness and thus reach the true consciousness within.
But in order to wake people up, you have to shake them. Gurdjieff's teaching
system involved unconventional methods: hard, physical labor; tasks beneath
one's social or cultural status; intense emotionalism; exercise; and complicated
dance movements. He called his methods "shocks", designed to change one's
preconceived notions of self and further the process of self-awareness.
His birth dateGurdjieff gave it as 1866is disputed. He was
born in Alexandropol in the Caucasus mountains in Russia, near the Turkish
border. His father was Greek and his mother Armenian. At the age of 17,
he left home and went to Tiflis in Georgia. He supported himself by a
variety of jobsa constant theme throughout his lifeand met
others who, like him, were looking for answers to life. He became a 'seeker
of truth' (which was the name of a group of like-minded people who gathered
round him a decade or so later).
Towards
the end of this phase, in 1911, he took a vow to lead an "absolutely unnatural
life, absolutely irreconcilable in every way with the traits that had
entrenched themselves in my individuality". The significance of this vow
can be simply stated: true knowledge arises when we are challenged, not
when we are comfortable. It is a constant theme in Gurdjieff's life and
work.
The second phase of Gurdjieff's life begins in 1912, when he emerges on
to the public stage for the first time. He appears in Moscow, gets married
and gradually begins to attract pupils. At the same time, the man who
was to become Gurdjieff 's Boswell, P.D. Ouspensky, makes his entry. His
account of his first meeting with Gurdjieff in a Moscow cafe is worth
quoting:
"I saw a man of an oriental type, no longer young, with a black mustache
and piercing eyes, who astonished me first of all because he seemed to
be disguised and completely out of keeping with the place and its atmosphere...
Seated here in this little cafe, where small dealers and commission agents
met together, in a black overcoat with a velvet collar and a black bowler
hat, he produced the strange, unexpected and almost alarming impression
of a man poorly disguised, the sight of whom embarrasses you because you
see he is not what he pretends to be and yet you have to speak and behave
as though you did not see it."
This incident exemplifies a constant theme in Gurdjieff's teaching: that
'ordinary' life is nothing more than identification with roles that are
mechanically adopted; hence one way of breaking out of them is to deliberately
adopt a difficult or 'unconvincing' role. And the point, of course, is
that Gurdjieff taught this by exampledoing it himself.
After
five relatively settled years, during which Gurdjieff taught his methods
in Moscow in the form recorded by Ouspensky in search of the miraculous,
the Russian revolution took place. In 1917, Gurdjieff and his pupils started
on a complicated journey through Europe, and eventually settled in 1922
in France, buying a large chateau 40 miles outside Paris in the forest
of Fontainebleau near Avon. It became the home of the institute for the
harmonious development of man, the center of Gurdjieff's teaching, which
operated till 1924, and was eventually sold in 1933. Apart from nine trips
to USA, Gurdjieff stayed in France until his death in 1949.
Gurdjieff was arguably the first really independent teacher in the West,
probably the most influential, and possibly the most difficult to get
along with. He was familiar with Madame H.P.
Blavatsky'sTheosophical
Society and other occult schools. But instead of embracing any organized
occult teaching, he devised his own.
Consciousness is central to Gurdjieff's teaching, and has four levels:
sleep, so-called waking consciousness, self-remembering, and objective
consciousness. Normal consciousness is nearly always passive, mechanical
and automatic. The path to realization is self-remembering-consciousawareness
of surroundings and the self in the situation. Its outcome is the fourth
state, objective consciousness, in which one sees things as they really
are.
Gurdjieff called his system the fourth way, or the way of the sly or cunning
man. He explained that traditionally, there were three paths to immortality:
those of the fakir (physical), the monk (emotional), and the yogi (intellectual).
The fakir undergoes physical privations to subserve his body to his will.
The monk possesses great faith and gives himself to his emotional commitment
to God. The yogi studies and ponders the mysteries of life. Yet each misses
out on the other two aspects of his personality.
Correspondingly, there are three centers or 'brains', which operate in
all human beings. But, says Gurdjieff, they are usually out of balance.
For example, the intellect, when applied to situations that require a
sensitivity to feelings, produces abstract concepts that miss the point;
or emotion brings "nervousness, feverishness and hurry" into situations
where calm judgment is required. So, in effect, there are two kinds of
imbalance: what may be called individual neurosis (centers try to do the
work that is proper to one of the others), and 'spiritual lopsidedness'
(no one center can reveal the whole nature of man).
The
solution to this lack of balance is 'the Fourth Way'. One learns to balance
the three centers and thereby become aware of what was previously hidden
or distorted. This is the beginning of consciousness in the true sense;
one is able to act and to know what one is doing. People do not need to
suffer physical, emotional or intellectual tortures, but merely start
from their own life experiences. They work on themselves as they are,
trying to harmonize all paths and using every cunning trick they know
to keep themselves 'awake'. This was not an immutable system, however.
Gurdjieff's ideas changed as circumstances warranted, so he forbade his
students to write them down and disseminate them.
He used hypnotism as a primary tool. He had acquired extensive, albeit
unorthodox medical knowledge on his travels, and believed that the tempo
of the blood altered at adolescence to accommodate humankind's normal
'asleep' state. He claimed that he possessed new hypnotic techniques that
would alter the blood's tempo to break through these so-called 'buffers'
and evoke the unconscious.
Gurdjieff also held that people must study under those who have escaped
their own robot existence: a teacher, a man who Knows. By his 'shock'
methods, the student begins to lose all preconceived notions and to unify
his or her various selvesthe 'I'sin harmony. By working on
oneself, one can rise above one's mechanical existence, make a soul, and
attain immortality.
The intellectual and upper class students participated in strenuous manual
labor and complicated dance exercises. They attended lectures on science,
languages, hypnotism and music.
They learned Sufi breathing and dance techniques. They were awakened at
all hours to work or just to 'be alert'. They might be asked to stop whatever
they were doing and remain like statues for minutes at a time. They lived
frugally and communally, yet were forced to join Gurdjieff in his Rabelaisian
feasts and drinking parties.
After 1924, Gurdjieff no longer taught, but began writing down his theories
and world view. Yet, other than The Herald of Coming Good, which
he published and then withdrew, he did not allow any other work of his
to be published. He practiced some hypnotic healing, relied on the largesse
of rich widows, and otherwise lived on the fringes through World War II
until his death in October 1949, aged 83.
His years in the West amount to this: he started his institutebut
did not keep it going; he had no formal groups for long periods of timeyet
at his death, he said that a nucleus (a group) was essential; he worked
for years on his bookswhich didn't appear in his lifetime; and he
constantly made things difficultboth for others and himself.
However, there is evidence that he was able to benefit people in an extraordinary
way. Fritz Peters, serving in the US army in 1945, in his book Remembering
Gurdjieff recalls arriving out of the blue at Gurdjieff's Paris flat
in a state of nervous collapse:
"I
remember being slumped over the table, sipping my coffee, when I began
to feel a strange uprising of energy within myselfI stared at him,
automatically straightened up, and it was as if a violent, electric blue
light emanated from him and entered into me. As this happened, I could
feel the tiredness drain out of me, but at the same moment his body slumped
and his face turned gray as if it was being drained of life. I looked
at him, amazed, and when he saw me sitting erect, smiling and full of
energy, he said quickly: 'You all right nowwatch food on stoveI
must go'... He had gone for perhaps 15 minutes while I watched the food,
feeling blank and amazed because I had never felt any better in my life...
I was equally amazed when he returned to the kitchen to see the change
in him; he looked like a young man again, alert, smiling, sly and full
of good spirits."
The two views on Gurdjieff can be stated in terms of his own teaching:
the first holds that he acted entirely from essence and never from personality
(though he may have made use of personality); the second says that personality
did get the better of him on occasion. Essence is what one is born withcall
it heredity, innate character or whatever. Personality is what one acquires
by education
and upbringing. Essence is one's own; personality is not and can be radically
changed. Essence can also be developed but not in the same way as personality.
Essence requires struggle or danger to grow, not because danger is inherently
valuable but because it provides the possibility that one will act consciously.
Most of his closest students eventually rejected Gurdjieff the man for
Gurdjieffian teachings. Ouspensky formally separated from him in 1923
and rejected his theories outright in 1931. Another famous student, A.R.
Orage, editor of the British journal The New Age, took
Gurdjieff's ideas to New York and developed what was called 'the Oragean
version'. He also formally rejected Gurdjieff in 1931. After Gurdjieff's
death, his students broke their silence and began publishing his life
and works. The first, and most reputed, was Ouspensky's. It was followed
by Gurdjieff's masterwork, Beelzebub's Tales to his Grandson (1950),
which had circulated among his pupils for years, known only as The
Book. Later, Meetings with Remarkable Men, his 'autobiography',
was published in 1960, and Life is Real Only Then, When 'I Am'
in the early 1970s.
THE
MAGIC CIRCLE
In
the middle of a circle drawn on the ground stood one of the little boys, sobbing
and making strange movements, and the others were standing at a certain distance
laughing at him. I was puzzled and asked what it was all about.
I learned
that the boy in the middle was a Yezidi, that the circle had been drawn round
him and that he could not get out of it until it was rubbed away. The child was
indeed trying with all his might to leave this magic circle, but he struggled
in vain. I ran up to him and quickly rubbed out part of the circle, and immediately
he dashed out and ran away as fast as he could...
The Yezidis are a
sect living in Transcaucasia, mainly in the regions near Mount Ararat. They are
sometimes called devil-worshippers.
Many years after the incident just
described, I made a special experimental verification of this phenomenon and found
that, in fact, if a circle is drawn round a Yezidi, he cannot of his own volition
escape from it. Within the circle he can move freely, and the larger the circle,
the larger the space in which he can move, but get out of it he cannot. Some strange
force, much more powerful than his normal strength, keeps him inside. I myself,
although strong, could not pull a weak woman out of the circle; it needed yet
another man as strong as I.
If a Yezidi is forcibly dragged out of a
circle, he immediately falls into the state called catalepsy, from which he recovers
the instant he is brought back inside. But if he is not brought back into the
circle, he returns to a normal state, as we ascertained, only after either thirteen
or twenty-one hours.
To bring him back to a normal state by any other
means is impossible. At least my friends and I were not able to do so, in spite
of the fact that we already possessed all the means known to contemporary hypnotic
science for bringing people out of the cataleptic state. Only their priests could
do so, by means of certain short incantations.
From Meetings
with Remarkable Men by G.I. Gurdjieff; Arkana/Penguin, 1988